Compromise means we get something and weegxve something. What are we saying we get? Plum committee assignments in return for no progressive bill ever passing the House?
The compromise is that Jefferies is a wet noodle. He can be incentivized and coerced into giving progressives a fair shot, for all his whining about “socialism” he’s met with a lot of progressives, and they came out of those meetings convinced he can be worked with
The public overwhelmingly supports progressives, we have a very good chance of building a large coalition in the party this Congress, and building on that moving forward to really get things accomplished. But right the progressive wing is a bunch of junior members and outcasts, it will take time to develop relationships and learn how to pull the levers
The other options are either someone more capable of actually whipping votes, which would not be good for us
Or a card carrying progressive, but we don’t have anyone established enough to whip votes effectively for that. Assuming we could even win a vote. They’d also be in the hot seat - if we don’t get things done, it’ll kill the political momentum… People always blame the president, then the majority leaders
When things move slowly (and I’m sure they will), in two years we can blame our failures on weak leadership and claim our wins for progressives
Jefferies doesn’t have the leadership skills to rat fuck us on his own. He’ll go where the wind blows, he responds to public pressure and has a political career ahead of him to worry about. He’s not an ally but he is a weak enemy
Shumer is different. He has been proven able and willing to rat fuck the party after one phone call, in a matter of hours no less. His political career is also basically over already, he’s going to cash out if we leave him in place
Politics is a bullshit game, a weak enemy is very probably better than a weak ally in this case
Because we literally do have to. It’s entirely up to the Congress members at this point, and they’ve decided this is the best path forward
I’ve done nothing but lay out what seem to be the reasoning and benefits of this choice for progressives, but ultimately no one is running against Jefferies. We don’t have a vote in this, it’s not a very good system, but it’s the one we have right now
I mean, you could write to your congresspeople, but I think getting scheumer out is way more important. There’s benefits to keeping Jefferies, but they do not apply to Schumer… He’s proven willing and able to ratfuck us in a matter of hours
A call for a removing the speaker of the house can happen at any time by a simple majority. We are not confined to just one january election for this. We need to be consistent now and in the future that leadership records like this one dont represent the people and are flatly unacceptable for any democrat to serve. Shrugging and moving forward as if this can never ever happen is a recipe for continuing to lose. We have to put our foot down and leave it down. If we dont have the votes now we need to build the support for it over time by bringing it up every single day on every single issue until ignoring it is untenable. This is a marathon, not a sprint with a finish line. If theres one thing the republicans will get behind, its removing a dem speaker-- just for the thrill of doing it.
If we dont have the votes now we need to build the support for it over time by bringing it up every single day on every single issue until ignoring it is untenable.
Why? Those priorities are completely backwards. Passing other bills will establish junior members and create political momentum for progressives. Postponing progress to remove Jefferies is ass backwards
The entire reason progressives are doing so well is the demand for action from the people - if Jefferies becomes an obstruction to that, then it becomes the priority to remove him. If he doesn’t, we get to make the county better… That’s the entire reason we need progressives in power in the first place
This is a marathon, not a sprint with a finish line.
Exactly…What does removing Jefferies give us right now? The momentary satisfaction of firing him? He’s one asshole among many
It doesn’t matter who sits in the fancy chair, what matters is the work.
We need to unfuck our country, and if it means letting Jefferies get on the progressive bandwagon and save his political career, fine.
If it means we need to oust Schumer, fantastic, but not because of how satisfying it’ll be - it’s because Schumer is a major obstacle to the work.
Everything that doesn’t move us closer to our goals is a distraction.
A call for a removing the speaker of the house can happen at any time by a simple majority.
So why do this now? Starting a fight with Jefferies at this stage would be a distraction. He’s met with progressive leaders and they were convinced them he’d work with them, and a cooperative Jefferies is the best case scenario (for now) - it means a more cohesive voting block and a scapegoat to take the heat while progressives will claim the victories
Jefferies will get a chance to improve his popularity and maybe continue his political career beyond his next election, but he’s a weak leader and has no charisma. He can’t be trusted, but he can be used and safely set aside when the time comes
Currently keeping Jefferies is to our advantage. When that changes, we change Jefferies
Exactly…What does removing Jefferies give us right now?
It doesn’t matter who sits in the fancy chair, what matters is the work.
We need to unfuck our country, and if it means letting Jefferies get on the progressive bandwagon and save his political career, fine.
I dont know where you get the idea that jeffries will “get on the progressive bandwagon”. Thats a drug fueled fantasy if I’ve ever heard one. If you dont understand the logic of very publicly removing heavily bribed people from positions of power who have never shown an ounce of wavering toward progressivism even after that election wave – I dont know what to tell you. I am starting to suspect you arent commenting in good faith so have yourself a good day.
I bet you struggle to understand a lot of things. But to clarify, only one of us is urging people to do nothing about our Jeffries problem and thats you buddy.
No one has ever accused him of leadership, but at least he can’t whip votes to backstab everyone
I don’t like or respect Jefferies, but he’s a compromise I could live with
Schumer on the other hand…
Compromise means we get something and weegxve something. What are we saying we get? Plum committee assignments in return for no progressive bill ever passing the House?
The compromise is that Jefferies is a wet noodle. He can be incentivized and coerced into giving progressives a fair shot, for all his whining about “socialism” he’s met with a lot of progressives, and they came out of those meetings convinced he can be worked with
The public overwhelmingly supports progressives, we have a very good chance of building a large coalition in the party this Congress, and building on that moving forward to really get things accomplished. But right the progressive wing is a bunch of junior members and outcasts, it will take time to develop relationships and learn how to pull the levers
The other options are either someone more capable of actually whipping votes, which would not be good for us
Or a card carrying progressive, but we don’t have anyone established enough to whip votes effectively for that. Assuming we could even win a vote. They’d also be in the hot seat - if we don’t get things done, it’ll kill the political momentum… People always blame the president, then the majority leaders
When things move slowly (and I’m sure they will), in two years we can blame our failures on weak leadership and claim our wins for progressives
Jefferies doesn’t have the leadership skills to rat fuck us on his own. He’ll go where the wind blows, he responds to public pressure and has a political career ahead of him to worry about. He’s not an ally but he is a weak enemy
Shumer is different. He has been proven able and willing to rat fuck the party after one phone call, in a matter of hours no less. His political career is also basically over already, he’s going to cash out if we leave him in place
Politics is a bullshit game, a weak enemy is very probably better than a weak ally in this case
Why should any of us “live with” a compromise when we dont have to?
Because we literally do have to. It’s entirely up to the Congress members at this point, and they’ve decided this is the best path forward
I’ve done nothing but lay out what seem to be the reasoning and benefits of this choice for progressives, but ultimately no one is running against Jefferies. We don’t have a vote in this, it’s not a very good system, but it’s the one we have right now
I mean, you could write to your congresspeople, but I think getting scheumer out is way more important. There’s benefits to keeping Jefferies, but they do not apply to Schumer… He’s proven willing and able to ratfuck us in a matter of hours
A call for a removing the speaker of the house can happen at any time by a simple majority. We are not confined to just one january election for this. We need to be consistent now and in the future that leadership records like this one dont represent the people and are flatly unacceptable for any democrat to serve. Shrugging and moving forward as if this can never ever happen is a recipe for continuing to lose. We have to put our foot down and leave it down. If we dont have the votes now we need to build the support for it over time by bringing it up every single day on every single issue until ignoring it is untenable. This is a marathon, not a sprint with a finish line. If theres one thing the republicans will get behind, its removing a dem speaker-- just for the thrill of doing it.
Why? Those priorities are completely backwards. Passing other bills will establish junior members and create political momentum for progressives. Postponing progress to remove Jefferies is ass backwards
The entire reason progressives are doing so well is the demand for action from the people - if Jefferies becomes an obstruction to that, then it becomes the priority to remove him. If he doesn’t, we get to make the county better… That’s the entire reason we need progressives in power in the first place
Exactly…What does removing Jefferies give us right now? The momentary satisfaction of firing him? He’s one asshole among many
It doesn’t matter who sits in the fancy chair, what matters is the work.
We need to unfuck our country, and if it means letting Jefferies get on the progressive bandwagon and save his political career, fine.
If it means we need to oust Schumer, fantastic, but not because of how satisfying it’ll be - it’s because Schumer is a major obstacle to the work.
Everything that doesn’t move us closer to our goals is a distraction.
So why do this now? Starting a fight with Jefferies at this stage would be a distraction. He’s met with progressive leaders and they were convinced them he’d work with them, and a cooperative Jefferies is the best case scenario (for now) - it means a more cohesive voting block and a scapegoat to take the heat while progressives will claim the victories
Jefferies will get a chance to improve his popularity and maybe continue his political career beyond his next election, but he’s a weak leader and has no charisma. He can’t be trusted, but he can be used and safely set aside when the time comes
Currently keeping Jefferies is to our advantage. When that changes, we change Jefferies
I dont know where you get the idea that jeffries will “get on the progressive bandwagon”. Thats a drug fueled fantasy if I’ve ever heard one. If you dont understand the logic of very publicly removing heavily bribed people from positions of power who have never shown an ounce of wavering toward progressivism even after that election wave – I dont know what to tell you. I am starting to suspect you arent commenting in good faith so have yourself a good day.
I could say the same, I struggle to understand why a leftist would care more about demoting Jefferies than actual progress
I can’t tell if your political understanding ends is just team sports, or if you want pointless infighting to prevent accomplishing anything
It sounds a whole lot like the “advice” MAGA media loves offering to the Democrats
I bet you struggle to understand a lot of things. But to clarify, only one of us is urging people to do nothing about our Jeffries problem and thats you buddy.