We can give reperatuons to someone falsely impriaoned. We can’t do a single damn thing about someone dead.

I never said anything should be hidden. I said you can’t make an incoruptuble system. So permenant actions should never be taken.

Thats my moral line.

I said nothing about how democratic, or concealed anything should be. I’m believe you that you want that, and I agree it would be good, healthy, and required for a functioning modern justice system.

But it still needs to account for when people you disagree with get power, and pervert the system.

If you never give the power of execution, than its a lot harder, and requires a lot more coverup to start exciting people.

Also, were seeing right now how far that paper you talk about is worth. Again, as ita being weilded against my trans siblings all across the states.

We have bills in states calling for execution of pedofiles

https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/former-florida-lawmaker-mike-caruso-arrested-child-abuse-charges-1815137

And drag queens being charged with child sex crimes

https://thebridgehead.ca/2022/07/04/drag-queen-who-danced-for-kids-charged-with-25-counts-of-child-pornography/

Can you see why i have a problem with these points being so close?

Also, you say so long as people care. Thats a bold assumption, because clearly, they dont. When was the last time someone enjoyed jury duty?

I genuinely want to know your view point.

And after that, is a good example of a slippery slope argument. Which is to say, no I’m not.

But you wanna know what’s reversible? Incarceration. We can give money and an apology. You wanna know what you can’t undo? Death.

So to me, unless you have a system that can promises 100% guilty people are guilty, even with people using the system with dishonest intents, than no, Im not on board with the government killing anyone.

So why should we keep those people locked up? Because I dont want to give that much power to an entitity that is currently killing and raping trans siblings in prison. Never mind if they legally can kill them all.

Tl; Dr if you give a power, it can and will be wielded to abuse you. And there should be more limits there.

And you missed mine.

That its impossible to hold anyone to the standard you propose, because to allow it all, means it can be manipulated for others purpose.

Why give the execution power to someone else?

In the day an age of being able to deep fake convincing evidence on a whim, I dont think the government should have the power to kill anyone. Period.

Plus, death is too easy. Watching the world move without you in it though…

Removed by mod

Removed by mod

Removed by mod

Removed by mod

Removed by mod

Removed by mod

Yup!

I’m a successful software developer with friends and I own my house.

You need to find better material.

Nope! Full of people and games and everything!

Like I said, lolololol

Bitch, I host the best parties.

Cope harder troll.

Is the logic in the room with us? Because it’s certainly not between your ears.

Took a look at your profile. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oavMtUWDBTM

If a toddler hands you a phone, do you not answer it?

If they asked to be called a pirate do you say no?

Why is name/pronouns different? They can’t control those?

Look, I’m a trans woman, and I ‘knew’ at that age. Did i know what it was? No!

But I clearly wasnt acting like a boy either. They know.

I agree that the constructs are stupid. Thats not the conterveraal thing you said though.

At that age you know what is appropriate gender affirming care? Calling them whatever random bullshit name they want to be called, and however they want to be referred to. For most children, it could just be a phase. But there’s no harm in indulging age appropriate care.

My full opnion on what I’m am expert in is already posted in this thread. My own health care and experience.

You asked for a viewpoint on one I can not provide. As I’m not a medical care expert. I defer to those I’ve already mentioned.

And that doesn’t really address the second part. Your asking a trans woman to be an expert in something the vast majority of us are not. Your asking a minority to be an expert and a representivie of the community as a whole. Rather than the individual they are. My background is physics. I can answer quantum questions no problem. I can even talk stattics in a lot of different contexts. But medical care is not one.

Its a common, but overhwleming, ask to be that expert, representative, or (calling it what it is) token.

Thats why I’m rejecting the question. Not because it was asked in bad faith. But That it has no business being asked of a random asshat on the internet. And at no point should you trust the answer anyways.

And not to be rude, please do your own research here.

I’m not saying this to be mean, I’m. saying it because I’m a random asshat on the internet. Find trusted sources, and find people who know more than me, an anon asshat.

Also, Its not always… Good… To ask the repressed minioroty for education. Its fully well intentioned. But your deferring to my opniom as if I’m a medical expert. When I’m at most an expert in my own health care.

My opinions om care are informed by opinions like paediatricians and other medical professional associations, all of whom say this care is safe.

I linked in another comment these were first used in the early 80s, 45 years ago. There’s TONs of info.

Now, like I said, not a medical expert. But I do have an acemic experience (degree in physics). I’ll say a good start is google scholor. Or looking for information on trusted places, like the medical associations.

Thats not to say there aren’t side effects, there’s always risk with medical decisions. On both sides.

There are many trans kids who kill them selves because transitioning isnt an option available to them. So saying ‘no’ to it, also has real risks.

Edit: I provided a link in another reply

https://www.jeremypbushnell.com/unfinished_everything/The history of puberty blockers - affirmative care.html

I don’t think the long term effects of puberty blocking are fully understood and in my opinion not worth the risk.

Based on what? Thats the problem here. You have this opniom, based on 0 supplied facts. This isnt new medicine. This is decades and decades of medical knowledge here.

https://www.jeremypbushnell.com/unfinished_everything/The history of puberty blockers - affirmative care.html

Were walking 45 years here.

Edit:

Was your daughter offered/suggested blockers?

Because it sounds like you did the right thing, listened to medical advice, and got the correct advice. So now other people shouldnt have it?

What medical change? Because your options were a lot leas than you think.

The only one available to a 10 year old is puberty blockers. Those are 100% reversible, and are commonly used outside of trams health care. Theyre used to delay the onset of development. The process restart the moment you stop taking them. No long teem effects have been found the several times I’ve done literature review. If you have one please send me a peer review paper.

This also is not done on a whim. This would be done in coordination with a psycayrist that also would explore those feelings with them. If not a Dr then a therapist for aure. I would want someone trained to explore gender vs sexuality with before asking for puberty blockers.

And on a different note. Let’s say you did let your daughter experiment with gender.

Go buy different name and pronouns, feel those don’t fit, and go back? Like what’s the long term damage. All I see is someone that comes out more confident that they’re a woman after that?

I fail to see any long term damage that would have happened, even if you did medical intervention.