

They’re using the ADLs definition of antisemitism.
They call everything antisemitic.


They’re using the ADLs definition of antisemitism.
They call everything antisemitic.
Can you post the evidence against Proton?


Right. I forgot that Americans think anything older than 100 years is ancient history.


No they absolutely weren’t. Commonwealth only worked to promote cooperation between member states. It was not like it had any real power over any of the member states.
How would you categorize the status of Canada vis a vis Britain before the Balfour declaration?
No because if they tried, it wouldn’t work. Which makes Canada NOT a vassal state. And it wasn’t not even in theory.
Do you realize that’s exactly what, “For all practical purposes…” means?


It depends on how pedantic we want to get.
Technically, Canada was a vassal of the UK until fairly recently. The laws dismantling that technicality started in 1926 and were mostly finalized in 1982. They still have an odd vestige of that where the Canadia monarch is defined as whoever happens to be the British monarch at the time.
For all practical purposes, the Brits haven’t held sovereignty over Canada in ages.
While the US was never officially Canada’s suzerain, the vast differences in economies, militaries, and populations mean that diplomatic and trade negotiations are tilted in the favor of the US.
The whole advantage of soft power over hard power is that it enforces vassalage without looking like it’s enforcing vassalage.


There’s a substantial school of philosophy that holds that continuously celebrating the first time someone from group X does thing Y tends to degrade public opinion of X, rather than supporting it.
The reasoning is that if the public mostly hears about group X in terms of the first time they did something that someone else has done, it entrenches the idea that group X is behind whoever did it first.
It essentially claims that celebrating firsts is initially good for group X but becomes negative over time. They would point out that the promise of “paving the way” rarely pans out. We saw the first woman elected as prime minister in 1960. People born then could be grandparents today and it’s still relatively rare to see women as the head of state.
From that perspective such articles would better support various groups if they focused on the accomplishments of the subjects rather than their identity. We don’t generally celebrate Ada Lovelace as the first female programmer; we celebrate her as the first programmer.
Note that I’m also making an assumption in terms of goals. The above only makes sense if you believe that it’s more important for an article to convince non-believers than to reassure believers.
They use the IHRA definition of antisemitism. It’s broader than just antizionism.
https://holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definition-antisemitism